
You pay an agency every month. They send reports. They have calls with you. Everyone is polite.
But when you check your bank balance and your sales, you wonder: is this actually working?
It is a fair question, and a good agency would want you to ask it. Here is how to find out.
Start with what you agreed
Open your original proposal or contract. What did the agency say it would deliver? Content, ads, leads, rankings, reporting? Compare that list with what you have received.
If the promises were vague ("increase brand awareness"), that is part of the problem. Fix it now by agreeing on clear targets.
Ten signs it is working
- You can see leads or sales linked to their work. Not just likes, but real enquiries.
- You understand the reports. They explain what happened and why, in plain language.
- They tell you what did not work. Honest agencies share failures and what they will change.
- You own your accounts. Ad accounts, domain, analytics and social profiles are in your name.
- There is a clear plan. You know what is being done this month and why.
- They ask about your business. Your margins, your best customers, your sales process.
- Tracking is set up properly. They can show where leads come from.
- Costs are transparent. You know the agency fee and the ad spend separately.
- Communication is steady. You get replies in a reasonable time without chasing.
- They push back sometimes. Good partners disagree when needed.
Red flags
- You cannot log into your own ad accounts
- Reports show impressions and reach but never leads or sales
- Every month's story is "we are building momentum"
- They promise to rank you first on Google in 30 days
- They avoid questions about cost per lead
- Strategy does not change even when results are poor
- Contracts lock you in with heavy penalties and no clear deliverables
Questions to ask in your next call
- "What was our cost per lead this month, and how does that compare with last month?"
- "Which campaign or post brought the most enquiries?"
- "What are you testing next, and why?"
- "If you were me, what would you stop doing?"
- "How many leads turned into sales, as far as we know?"
Watch how they answer. A confident team gives numbers or admits they do not know yet and offers to find out.
Do your part too
Agencies need some things from you to deliver results.
- Timely approvals and access
- Honest information about which leads were good or bad
- Fast follow-up on enquiries (see speed to lead)
- A decent offer and a website that converts
Even a great agency cannot fix a slow response time or an uncompetitive offer.
Give it a fair window
Paid ads can show signals in a few weeks, but need testing. SEO and content usually need three to six months. Judge each by the right timeline, and agree milestones at the start. CPL, ROAS and CAC explains how to read the numbers.
If it is not working
Do not jump straight to cancelling. First share your concerns in writing, ask for a 30-day improvement plan with specific targets, and see how they respond. If nothing changes, take your accounts and assets and move on. If you are weighing up other options, read agency, freelancer or in-house.
We are open about how we work at Blackcrest Media, including who owns the accounts and how we report. You can see how on our digital marketing page.




